North Yorkshire Council is facing a fresh allegation of unlawful decision-making over plans for a motorway service area (MSA) near Boroughbridge.
Campaign group Kirby Hill Residents Against Motorway Services (RAMS) has written to the council’s monitoring officer Barry Khan, raising concerns about a new planning application linked to the proposed Vale of York services scheme.
The group claims a recently submitted Section 73 application – often used to vary planning conditions – is being used in an attempt to “rescue” the development after doubts were raised about whether the original outline permission had expired.
RAMS argues that if the original permission has lapsed, it cannot be revived through such an application.
Group chair Gareth Owens said:
“This looks like an attempt to fix a fundamentally flawed planning position after the event.
“If the outline permission has already expired, it cannot simply be revived or repaired through a later Section 73 application.
“Even if the outline permission has not expired, there are strict legal limits on what a Section 73 application can be used for. It cannot fix a defective permission.”
The dispute centres on whether a previous application was submitted in time to keep the existing outline planning consent alive.
RAMS maintains the deadline passed in April 2024, meaning there is no valid permission in place.
Mr Owens said:
“If that is correct, there is no extant permission to which reserved matters can attach.
“That means the application before the council is invalid and cannot lawfully be determined.”
The council rejects that view and says it has taken external legal advice.
However, campaigners have questioned the transparency of that advice, claiming local councillors have not been given access to any written legal opinion.
Mr Owens added:
“The council says it has taken legal advice, but neither councillors nor the public have been shown the legal reasoning behind its position.
“That lack of transparency is increasingly concerning given the seriousness of the legal issues involved.”
The row follows the High Court quashing a separate decision by the authority to approve a motorway service area at Catterick, after finding the council had acted unlawfully.
The Boroughbridge scheme, promoted by Welcome Break, would see a large service station built on land near the A1(M).
RAMS has now asked the monitoring officer to consider issuing a formal report on the matter before any decision is taken, warning the council risks repeating past planning errors if it proceeds.
In response, the council’s head of development management, Martin Grainger, said:
“This is a live planning application which will be considered by members of our strategic planning committee on a future date.
“All views and opinions that have been submitted to us in relation to the application will be taken into consideration before a decision is made.”
Schemes in Harrogate and Ripon receive grants from Mayor's £2.4million High Street Fund
Ripon Grammar School receives 'glowing' report from inspectors
Record breaking year for families receiving first choice primary schools
Four-man assault on Harrogate road leaves victim with head injury
Harrogate care home hits jackpot with Casino Royale fundraiser
Coppice Valley Primary School celebrates praise from Ofsted
Shortlist revealed for Harrogate Hospitality and Tourism Awards
New registration scheme set to launch at recycling centres
New travelling circus to visit Valley Gardens this summer
Classical music with a twist: Madhouse Orchestra heads to Harrogate
New science-led prevention clinic launches in Harrogate
Theakston Old Peculier Crime Writing Festival returns for 'biggest year ever'
Follifoot named among UK's poshest villages
Harrogate BID celebrates another successful dog show
Specialist school for autistic pupils to open in Harrogate
Details revealed for return of Masham Tractor Run
Harrogate man attempts to smash second world record at London Marathon
Vintage tractor run raises more than £5,000 for Harrogate cancer centre
Harrogate mum runs half marathon to raise £2,400 for rare skin condition charity
Controversial expansion of Harrogate bottled water plant set for go-ahead
