Planning officers have given their backing to controversial plans for a large solar farm and battery energy storage system (BESS) near Knaresborough.
An application for a 49.9MW solar scheme and BESS on almost 100 hectares of land between Scotton, Brearton and Farnham will be recommended for approval when North Yorkshire Council’s strategic planning committee meets next week.
The recommendation has been made despite 244 objections lodged by residents, with campaigners from Stop Scotton Solar Farm collecting more than 600 signatures on a petition against the scheme.
Objections were filed by Knaresborough Town Council and four parish councils.
Concerns have also been raised by the council’s landscape and conservation officers and Historic England.
Objectors have highlighted fears over the loss of productive farmland, the industrialisation of the countryside, traffic during construction, fire risks associated with the battery energy storage system, impacts on wildlife, heritage assets and nearby public rights of way.
However, planning officers conclude that the benefits of the renewable energy scheme outweigh the identified harms and are recommending councillors approve the application, subject to conditions.
The applicant claims the development would generate about 47.8 gigawatt hours of electricity each year – enough to power around 13,450 homes annually – while avoiding an estimated 9,913 tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions each year compared with fossil fuel generation.
Officers say the proposal would make an important contribution towards national and local net zero targets.
The report acknowledges the development would cause a “major adverse impact” on the character of the site and surrounding landscape, even after 15 years, and accepts it would introduce industrial infrastructure into an otherwise rural setting.
The council’s landscape officer maintains there would be significant harm despite improvements to the planting and layout.
Planning officers also recognise the scheme would result in “less than substantial harm” to the setting of heritage assets, including the Grade II* listed Scotton Old Hall and its associated barn, while Historic England has maintained its objection despite revisions to the proposals.
About 83 per cent of the site is classed as best and most versatile agricultural land, but officers say the solar farm would be temporary, operating for 40 years before being removed, with sheep continuing to graze beneath the panels throughout its lifetime. They argue the land could then be restored to full agricultural use.
The application has been amended during its consideration, including moving the construction access away from Scotton Lingerfield Primary School following public objections and removing solar panels from several fields to reduce heritage impacts.
Recommending approval, planning officer Laura Bromley concluded in her report:
“It is concluded that the substantial public benefits of the provision of clean, renewable and secure energy would outweigh the identified harms to landscape character and visual impact, residential amenity, and to the significance of heritage assets that arise by way of changes to their settings.
“On balance, the proposed benefits outweigh the harms identified, and there are no material considerations which indicate otherwise.”
The strategic planning committee will discuss the application when it meets on Tuesday.
Ripon Grammar School girls and boys crowned cricket champions
Council accused of "letting the harm continue" after voting against school transport debate
Harrogate home care company named among UK's top 20
Free family community festival planned for Valley Gardens
Aldborough & Boroughbridge Show returns with new attractions
New deputy leader appointed at North Yorkshire Council
Police appeal after driver crashes into parked car in Knaresborough
Harrogate councillors accused of "childish political stunts" over no confidence vote
Controversial A1(M) services set for final approval
WATCH: Grove Road teacher is third to receive special end of term treat
Harrogate housing development set for expansion
Rossett School's sponsored walk raises £5,700 for charity
Record crowds enjoy opening day of Great Yorkshire Show
Police appeal after Bilton Co-op theft
'Disappointed' Harrogate Mayor thanks community after culture bid setback
Trio of charities to champion community spirit at Great Yorkshire Show
Fresh call for school transport rethink amid claim new policy could cost £5m a year
WATCH: Markington school teacher wins end of term treat
Pick-your-own-flower attraction to open near Harrogate this weekend
North Yorkshire Council leader issues warning over larger police forces
