Councillors approved 224 homes at Whinney Lane in Harrogate today which will also see a new primary school built.
The 12-hectare site is opposite the Squinting Cat pub on the edge of town and forms part of the allocation H51 in the Harrogate local development plan.
This document was agreed by the now-defunct Harrogate Borough Council in 2020 and maps out where housebuilding is permitted in the district.
The scheme put forward by housing developer Banks Group is the first of two applications for H51 which could eventually see more than 700 homes built on the former farming fields.
A second application is expected to come before councillors later this year.
North Yorkshire Council’s strategic planning committee this afternoon in Northallerton to consider the first application.
It will see 40% of the homes classed as affordable and all homes will be fitted with air-source heat pumps.
Banks Group said the scheme will help to meet a high demand for homes in the area.
But with up to 4,000 homes expected to be built in the western side of Harrogate there has been much debate about the impact it might have on the local road network.
Local Tory councillor John Mann said the number of proposed homes was “astonishing” and equates to a small town being “annexed” onto Harrogate without the appropriate infrastructure in place.
David Siddans from Harlow and Pannal Ash Residents Association said the group was not against housing being built at H51 but that proposals to improve roads in the area were inadequate.
Mr Siddans said:
“It leaves transport performing worse than at present with queues and delays leading to a worsening economic performance.”
However, a council officer said traffic modelling had suggested the scheme will not have a negative impact on roads around Whinney Lane.
Justin Hancock, planner at Banks Group, said the company was “extremely proud” of the scheme which he said will meet the needs of the community.
He said the developer has worked alongside the council on the West of Harrogate Parameters Plan and the West Harrogate Infrastructure Delivery Document which has resulted in more money being pledged towards infrastructure.
Mr Hancock added:
“We worked with local community groups for a number of years. We’ve listened and provided reassurance about how development will work.”
Banks Group will pay North Yorkshire Council £2.9m through a section 106 legal agreement towards local roads but Cllr Richard Foster (Conservative, Wharfedale) said he was disappointed that this won’t be spent on any immediate improvements.
An officer told councillors that Transdev’s number 6 bus will eventually run down Whinney Lane and into the site but this won’t begin until homes are built and residents have moved in.
With the site allocated for development in the local plan, Labour councillor for Northstead in Scarborough Eric Broadbent said the application “shines” when compared with other large schemes that have recently come before the council.
Cllr Broadbent added:
“It’s refreshing to have an application where everything has been looked at. A lot of hard work has gone into it.”
Chris Aldred (Liberal Democrat, High Harrogate & Kingsley) said he sympathised with local residents regarding transport but there were “a lot of good things” about the scheme.
Cllr Aldred said:
“People want to live in Harrogate and they’ll pay above market rate to live here. That’s why developers want to develop here and we have a line up of schemes coming on board.”

New Acute Medical Unit opens at Harrogate District Hospital
New show home opens for Harrogate house hunters
Darcey's Ball raises whopping £55,000 for Martin House
Local MP takes campaign to save Knaresborough castle to Parliament
Harrogate Town submit plans to build £2.75m training ground in Wetherby
Harrogate NHS awarded £2 million for cutting waiting times
Harrogate care home's Christmas ball raises £18,500
Local MP visits Harrogate College amid £20million redevelopment
New sandwich shop to open on Knaresborough Road
Yorkshire Baby Show announces return to Harrogate in spring
Weetons named as winners of Christmas shop window competition
Knaresborough Young Farmers announce return of Christmas tree collection service
Your Harrogate and Harrogate Town to partner for return of Local Hero Awards
Harrogate appoints night marshals for festive season
Search continues for missing man who could be in Harrogate
Harrogate dad living with epilepsy shares hope for festive season he can remember
Ripon BID named as finalist at national awards
Man arrested in Harrogate after hitting woman 'multiple times in the head'
Yorkshire Water finally lifts five-month hosepipe ban
Fundraiser launched to help Starbeck boy take his first independent steps


