A decision on plans to turn the site of a derelict petrol station in Ripon into six flats has been deferred.
Officers at North Yorkshire Council had recommended that the redevelopment of the Skellbank Garage, in Skellbank, was turned down when councillors on the Skipton and Ripon area planning committee met on Monday.
But councillors said they were minded to support the application subject.
Applicant Tate Fuel Oils Ltd had asked for permission to build a four-storey apartment block on the site, which has not been used for more than 20 years.
Three two-bed and three one-bed flats were proposed.
The application had the “strong” support of Ripon City Council, while Ripon Civic Society welcomed a change to the plans, which means a pitched rather than flat roof is proposed.
But in his report, council planning officer Mike Parkes said the open undercroft was not sympathetic with Ripon Conservation Area.
He added that the height of the eaves of the proposed building was higher than the neighbouring listed building and the development would be harmful to the setting of the property.
The officer also raised concerns that no ground stability report had been carried out despite the plot being in an area with shallow gypsum that could cause subsidence.
Councillors agreed that a gypsum report needed to be carried out and the applicant needed to agree to various planning conditions.
The application will be brought back before the committee at a later date for approval.
In 2003, Harrogate Borough Council approved a plan to demolish the petrol station in order to build eight flats, but the work never took place, and the permission has now lapsed.
A similar plan was submitted in 2016 but was then withdrawn three years later.
150 homes planned for green belt land near Harrogate
'Bonkers' burlesque show returns to Harrogate
North Yorkshire residents urged to recycle more household waste
Apple Throwing Championships return to Newby Hall
MPs urge Prime Minister to make A64 dualling a priority
Police appeal after radiator stolen from Ripon property
Ukrainian city thanks Knaresborough residents for ongoing humanitarian aid
New venue revealed for Harrogate vintage car meet
Body of man in his 60's discovered in Ripon canal
Harrogate MP vows to keep fighting for end-of-life choice
Holiday park expansion planned to meet need for more spacious pitches
Storm overflow investigation to begin on Stray in Harrogate
Ferrari worth more than £2 million spotted in Harrogate
Historic Ripon buildings open their doors for Heritage Open Days
Martin House doctor shares realities of children's palliative care in new book
Work gets underway on new Gail's Bakery in Harrogate
Police explain why more serious charges were not brought in Bailey Chadwick case
Wetherby MP accuses Prime Minister of 'class warfare' over Linton asylum plans
Ripon athlete launches extraordinary Three Peaks charity challenge
New pre-school officially opens in Harrogate
