Plans for a motorway service area (MSA) off the A1(M) in North Yorkshire have been approved despite a claim the scheme amounts to the "rape of the countryside".
North Yorkshire Council has granted planning permission for the Vale of York MSA at Kirby Hill, near Boroughbridge, which was first proposed 30 years ago.
The services will provide parking for 364 cars, 90 HGVs, 18 coaches, caravans and motorcycles, together with fuel filling stations, a drive-through coffee shop and amenity building.
Members of the council’s strategic planning committee voted in favour of the reserved matters application despite claims from objectors that unresolved legal questions remain over the scheme.
Gareth Owens, chair of the Kirby Hill Residents Against Motorway Services (RAMS), spoke at the meeting to question whether the application could be lawfully determined.
The group has questioned whether the application was submitted ahead of a deadline of April 2024 set when the outline application was approved in 2021 following a public inquiry.
Campaigners also claim the plans have been changed since the original application.
Mr Owens said:
“Land east of the A1, intended to return to agriculture, now contains permanent motorway service infrastructure.
“Additional best and most versatile agricultural land is permanently lost. The motorway bridge is higher, as is the elevated dumb-bell roundabout nearest Kirby Hill.
“The site drainage strategy and the number of surface water lagoons has changed. Yet members are still asked to rely on the outline environmental statement.”
But Nick Roberts, agent for applicant Welcome Break, described the issues raised by the campaigners as “red herrings”.
He added:
“Their claims do not withstand any scrutiny in your office report is clear on all of the allegations.
“The reserve matters application has been proven to be valid.”
Several councillors spoke against the plans at the meeting at County Hall, Northallerton.
Councillor Robert Windass said he stood by previous comments describing the scheme as the “rape of the countryside”.
He added:
“We’ve got prime agricultural land there which is being ruined forever. We’re going to put a petrol filling station that is not particularly required — there is one just down the road.”
Councillor Andy Brown said the committee was in a “ridiculous position” regarding the environmental features of the scheme.
He said:
“Solar panels on green fields was the proposal for the previous application, which we were recommended to vote for.
“Then we look at an application for a petrol station without a single solar panel, without any meaningful discussions about whether they’re possible.
“And we have to wave it through on that ground because there’s no legal basis on which we can insist on common sense, so that’s deeply disappointing.”
Other councillors said they did not like the plans but could see no reasons to disagree with the officer’s recommendation to approve.
Councillor Neil Swannick said the principle of development had already been established for the MSA, adding:
“I fully support the proposal though I don’t fully support the application, but it’s important we’re consistent.
“We’ve already approved it and I would recommend we support the officer’s recommendations to approve it again.”
Councillor Bob Packham said the residents’ concerns had been considered by the council’s officers and legal team.
He added:
“My view is we are not in a position to out-judge what their conclusions are."
The application was approved by nine votes to five with one abstention.
Mr Owens told the Local Democracy Reporting Service after the meeting that the campaign group was considering its position.
Harrogate-based Sporting Influence Foundation to tackle 24 climbs in 24 hours
Giant vegetables take centre stage at Harrogate Autumn Flower Show
Alpamare waterpark to be sold to 'protect its future' with private investment
Roadworks causing growing disruption in Harrogate and Knaresborough, officials admit
Yorkshire artist brings Harrogate's Old Market Hall back to life
Martin House hosts first children's palliative care conference
Judge appointed to lead inquiry into North Yorkshire mental health trust
Harrogate group raise more than £40,000 with cycle to Bordeaux
Scotton pub wins Tripadvisor award for seventh year running
Almost 2,000 people sign Knaresborough landslip petition
Police appeal after Range Rover damaged in Knaresborough
St Aidan's teacher recognised at national Teacher of the Year Awards
Bramham Park to host its first Christmas market
Harvest gown unveiled for flower show's 50th anniversary
Ripon's Mario's Restaurant named among Tripadvisor's top 10%
Harrogate Rugby Club reveals plans for clubhouse expansion and padel courts
Police appeal after Lister House minibus vandalised in Ripon
Council urged to "show me the money" and provide evidence of home-to-school policy change savings
Kate Mosse and Prue Leith among stars of Harrogate Literature Festival
Ripon among UK's top cities for missing parcels
