A senior North Yorkshire councillor has admitted that the authority's controversial home-to-school transport policy contains "errors".
Wharfedale Conservative councillor Richard Foster, executive member for managing our environment, said he hoped a post-implementation review would lead to the errors being addressed and exceptions to the policy being made in rural areas.
The mew rules, which only provide free transport to a child’s nearest school, have been criticised by parents because it means families cannot get paid transport to catchment school if it is not their closest.
In some rural areas, a journey to a closer school can mean a trip over remote high ground, which can be unsafe particularly in winter.
Councillor Andrew Murday, North Yorkshire Liberal Democrat councillor for the Pateley Bridge and Nidderdale division, spoke out against the policy change at a meeting of the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority (YDNPA).
The councillor, who like Cllr Foster is also a YDNPA member, said he had attended a recent public meeting in Kettlewell to discuss the impact of the policy change.
He added:
“The result is, particularly in remote rural areas, that families are left with very little alternative but to send their children to schools by transport that’s really on routes that are unsuitable.
“The problem is this discourages young families from moving to these areas and a school like Kettlewell, which has been under threat in the past, I think it’s the only school left in Upper Wharfedale, will find itself over the next few years under greater threat.”
In response, Cllr Foster questioned why the issue was brought up at a meeting of the national park authority.
He added:
“I think that through the policy implementation review, I am hopeful, I’m not confident, but I’m hopeful that some of these very remote isolated communities will be looked at as exceptions, because they are exceptions. I think we can all agree, really, they’re exceptions.”
The councillor said the policy was saving between £4m and £5m a year.
He added:
“(School transport) has gone from £25m to nearly £50m so we need to actually look at how we deliver this budget and what we do with it.
“The idea that some parents basically choose which school they send their child to and we pay for the transport for that child, it can’t continue if you know what I mean.
“There have been errors in that policy, I would say, where the exceptions haven’t been looked at, and that is why we’re doing the review as we speak.”
A spokesperson for the School Transport Action Group, which was formed to fight the change, said Cllr Foster was “operating on pure wishful thinking”.
They added:
“He was told that grammar schools would be excluded – they weren’t. Then he was told things would be sorted out in appeals – they weren’t.
“Now he’s saying it’ll be sorted by the delayed post-implementation review – it won’t be.
“He and his Conservative colleagues, who are all still backing this disastrous policy, need to wake up and smell the coffee.”
Martin House hits £2million fundraising target
Knaresborough choir celebrates double competition success
Charity burlesque night to be held in Harrogate
Police renew appeal following criminal damage in Knaresborough
Leeds Bradford Airport opens new multi-faith room
Plans for 46 new homes in Masham to be debated
Harrogate MP backs decision to release 'Andrew files'
Harrogate Town Women to face Leeds United
MP and Green Councillors call for Harrogate Spring Water decisions to be made in public
Harrogate local to take on The Great Wall of China this September
Harrogate named a finalist in the UK Wellbeing Living Awards 2026
North Yorkshire councillor describes parking fee increase as "stealth tax"
Total Wipeout-themed event to return to Harrogate
Oatlands Infants wins national award for inclusion
New local theatre company brings first play to Harrogate
Jail and Bail: How to support Harrogate Theatre fundraiser
Parking charge increase set to cost motorists an extra £3.5m
Tom Gordon reselected as Liberal Democrat candidate for Harrogate
Route timings revealed for Knaresborough Tractor Run
Pilot dies following aircraft crash near Masham, police confirm
