The mayor of Ripon says she will not resign despite a claim her position has become “untenable” following the outcome of a parish poll.
Of the 592 people who took part in Thursday’s poll, 317 voted ‘no’ and 271 voted ‘yes’ to the question ‘do you have confidence in Councillor Barbara Brodigan?’
A total of 12,696 electors were eligible to vote, meaning the turnout was just 4.66 per cent.
The poll took place amid ongoing upheaval at Ripon City Council following the departure of three members of staff.
Cllr Brodigan became mayor after the previous mayor, Councillor Jackie Crozier, resigned.
Proposer of the poll, Ripon resident, Brian McHugh said the outcome “clearly reflects the strong public outrage in her behaviour, which has now caused three months of chaos in Ripon”.
He added:
“Firstly, my thanks go to all those who voted and made the effort to participate in local democracy, as well as North Yorkshire’s election team.
“12,000 people have now had the opportunity to have their say on the leadership of Ripon City Council and the people have voiced their strong objection and lack of confidence in the Liberal Democrat Councillor Brodigan, so we hope that she will listen and respect what the city has said and stand aside.
“It is historic that a sitting Ripon mayor has received this vote of no confidence from the public and it surely makes her role untenable. She really is a lame duck mayor now.”
But Cllr Brodigan told the Local Democracy Reporting Service she would not be resigning and branded the poll a “total and utter waste of money”.
She added:
“The result only actually represents 2.5 per cent of the population, that’s all. That puts the whole thing into perspective.
“The returning officer said the cost would be between £5,000 and £6,000 for trying to find out that 2.5 per cent of the population have no confidence in me.”
Cllr Brodigan said she expected the result of the poll to be on the agenda of the next Ripon City Council meeting on December 8.
She added:
“Under normal circumstances, a parish poll is about local issues, but this has been a personal issue so it would be quite surprising if it is on the agenda.
“But I’ve no doubt it will be, because there will be certain counsellors who will like to discuss it. But, as it is not legally binding, I think that will also be a waste of time.”

Kirkby Overblow primary praised for 'love and joy' in glowing SIAMS report
'Best day on record': Harrogate café goes out with a bang on last day of trading
Police appeal for missing man could be in Harrogate
Harrogate and Knaresborough to feature in new North Yorkshire calendars
Knaresborough Christmas Tree Festival to return this week
Police video highlights dangers of drink and drug driving at Christmas
Teenager's cancer awareness film nominated for major award
100-year-old Harrogate resident shares secret to long life
Winners revealed for Harrogate Mumbler Awards 2025
Meet the Ripon teen living his football dream
Harrogate runner crowned winner of gruelling 100-mile race
Harrogate Homeless Project launches Christmas appeal
Frazer Theatre to hold second exclusive screening of Tinsel Town
Harrogate schools to sing 'Sleeps to Santa' Christmas countdown
Yorkshire Water says end of hosepipe ban is near as rainfall continues
Harrogate Town launches half season tickets
Artisan market at Fountains Abbey cancelled due to bad weather
Yorkshire Air Ambulance raises £52,000 at first ever fundraising ball
Harrogate school marks first anniversary of 'bike bus' initiative
Minskip to stage Christmas fayre and concert


