North Yorkshire Council has refused a fourth bid to turn The Birch Tree Inn in Wilsill into a holiday cottage.
The 110-year-old pub is a prominent landmark on the main road from Pateley Bridge to Harrogate but much of the building was converted into three holiday cottages in 2019 with the pub continuing to trade in a smaller area.
But after the pub reduced in size, planning documents say it has struggled to turn a profit despite attempts by the owner and two tenants.
It last served customers before the first Covid lockdown in March 2020 but did not reopen.
During each of the previous refusals, the council argued the pub’s owner had not marketed it as a pub sufficiently to prove that it was no longer viable.
This is a requirement of planning law when seeking to convert community facilities such as pubs.
A cover letter was attached to the latest application which argued a “substantial period of marketing” had occured and talks had also taken place with the local community about a potential sale.
However, the application received an objection from Pateley Bridge Town Council which claimed work to refurbish the pub had already begun with fittings already stripped out. It called on the council’s planning enforcement team to investigate.
The town council, which has an advisory role in local planning applications, confirmed there was interest in Pateley Bridge to buy the pub as a community asset.
In North Yorkshire Council’s refusal notice which was published on July 4, it says a site visit took place last month which revealed the pub had already been converted into holiday accommodation despite the application claiming works had not begun.
It said a domestic kitchen and bedroom were “clearly visible” where the pub toilets and seating area were supposed to be.
An agent was contacted by the council about this but did not send a response.
The council judged the conversion would have made it more difficult to market as a pub.
An officer wrote:
“It is unclear when the pub was converted to holiday accommodation but it is considered that this would have a material effect on the attractiveness and saleability of the pub.
"Marketing the pub for 12 consecutive months is not a convincing exercise when the site is no longer a pub, but already holiday accommodation.”

Harrogate Town confirm permenant transfer of Luke Hutchinson
Harrogate lollipop man, 80, to retire after 11 years
Harrogate pupil represents England at Commonwealth karate event
Harrogate Golf Day raises over £5,000 for Saint Michael's Hospice
Becky Hill to headline open-air summer concert at Harewood House
Harrogate Theatre announces Cinderella as next year's pantomime
'I hope we don't lose North Yorkshire Police': deputy leader joins mayor's concerns
Couple reveal vision for new food and drink destination near Ripon
Scaffolding comes down to reveal restored Ripon Town Hall
Harrogate ghost walk to raise money for dad of two with bowel cancer
Pig statue stolen from doorstep near Ripon
Your jewellery box could pay for Christmas this year
Harrogate businesses invited to thank customers on air this Christmas
Britain's Got Talent winners to perform at Great Yorkshire Show
Ofsted praises behaviour and wellbeing at Rossett Acre Primary
North Yorkshire Council takes over Alpamare waterpark ahead of planned sale
Harrogate MP urges ministers to publish asylum site costs
Harrogate pub named among UK's best for dog owners
Vehicle fire causes delays on A1(M) south of Boroughbridge
Ripley school choir to sing carols at castle Christmas market


